STAFF REPORTER
PESHAWAR : An independent study conducted by the Institute for Public Opinion Research (IPOR) has exposed serious weaknesses in the implementation of Pakistan Tobacco Board (PTB) regulations, raising questions about transparency, farmers’ rights and the growing risk of tobacco leaf entering undocumented and potentially illicit supply chains.
The findings have highlighted significant irregularities in tobacco purchasing practices, including the absence of formal agreements, below-official prices, cash transactions and procurement outside the established regulatory mechanism, suggesting that a parallel grey market may be operating beyond the effective oversight of the relevant authorities.
The study, titled Assessment of Tobacco-Leaf Production, Marketing and Purchasing Practices in Pakistan, surveyed 1,200 tobacco farmers in Swabi, Mardan and Charsadda, examining purchasing agreements, prices, payment methods and compliance with existing regulations.
Under the PTB’s regulatory framework, tobacco purchases are subject to government-notified weighted average price requirements aimed at protecting farmers. Tobacco companies and dealers are also required to fulfil their announced purchasing quotas, including additional surplus quantities allocated by the PTB.
However, the IPOR findings reveal a substantial gap between these regulatory requirements and actual market practices.
According to the study, 45 per cent of farmers had no written purchasing agreement before planting, while 52 per cent said they sold their tobacco to buyers with whom they had no direct written agreement.
The study also identified significant differences in the prices received by farmers. Those selling tobacco to multinational companies received an average of Rs720 per kilogram, compared with Rs559 from other companies and only Rs471 from dealers.
More alarmingly, among farmers who faced difficulties selling tobacco outside formal purchasing agreements, 85 per cent reported receiving offers below the official PTB price, raising serious concerns about the protection of growers against unfair market practices.
Payment arrangements have also emerged as a major area of concern. Among farmers involved in non-contracted sales, 52 per cent reported receiving payments in cash, while 36 per cent said they were paid on the spot.
Such transactions, particularly when tobacco is procured directly without passing through designated buying depots, weaken financial transparency, documentation and traceability. These practices also create opportunities for tobacco leaf to enter undocumented channels, potentially undermining the government’s efforts to control illicit tobacco trade.
The findings assume particular significance as the government continues its efforts to curb the illegal tobacco market, protect public revenue and strengthen regulatory enforcement across the tobacco sector. Weak oversight at the initial stage of the supply chain could compromise these efforts by allowing undocumented procurement to continue.
Commenting on the findings, IPOR Executive Director Tariq Junaid said the central issue was the lack of compliance with the existing regulatory framework governing tobacco purchases.
“The issue is the gaps in compliance with the regulatory framework governing tobacco purchasing. When tobacco is traded outside formal agreements through third-party buyers, farmers face greater uncertainty and the risk of receiving prices below those prescribed by the Pakistan Tobacco Board. Stronger enforcement of existing regulations is essential to address these gaps,” he said.
The study further found that 62 per cent of farmers considered increased purchasing agreements or higher procurement quotas from multinational tobacco companies the most important improvement required in the existing system. The finding reflects growers’ preference for predictable, structured and legally regulated purchasing arrangements.
Junaid stressed that greater accountability among buyers, effective monitoring of purchasing quotas and improved access to formal agreements were essential to protecting farmers and ensuring transparency in the tobacco market.
“Greater accountability of buyers, stronger oversight of purchasing quotas and improved access to formal agreements are critical to safeguarding farmers’ interests and ensuring a fair and transparent tobacco market,” he added.
The study has called for stricter implementation of existing PTB laws and regulations, stronger accountability across all purchasing channels, improved documentation and traceability of tobacco-leaf transactions, and effective monitoring of procurement activities.
It has also underscored the need for coordinated action by the relevant authorities to ensure that tobacco purchasing remains within the formal regulatory system.
The findings serve as a warning that merely having regulations on paper is not enough. Without effective enforcement, transparent purchasing mechanisms and accountability for all buyers, farmers will remain vulnerable to unfair prices while undocumented tobacco transactions could continue to threaten government revenue and efforts to eliminate the illicit tobacco trade.

